Product image pending

We track images separately from defect reports.

Kitchen Appliance

Amana AGR5844VDW

2 source-linked failure reports. Most reported: Electrical shock / short. Typical failure around 9.5 mo.

Reliability signal — · Insufficient data · data confidence Very Low

2 confirmed failure reports

Reliability summary

What is likely to go wrong, when it happens, and how expensive it can be — from source-linked failure reports. Counts are reports in our database, not a population failure rate.

Reliability signal

—

2 confirmed failure reports · Insufficient data · Data confidence: Very Low

Need at least 5 confirmed failure-signal reports before showing an A–F grade.

Most common issue
Electrical shock / short
Typical first failure
9.5 mo
Median of confirmed reports with timing
Median repair cost
—
Reported costs only · market varies
Highest reported repair
—
Not a quote · costs differ by country

What breaks?

Failure types

Click a type in the reports section below to filter.

  • Electrical shock / short1 · 50%
  • Fire / ignition1 · 50%

When does it break?

Failure timing

Months after purchase, using reports that included timing.

What does it cost?

Reported repair costs

Distribution of owner-reported repair costs— not a quote or guarantee. Labor and parts prices vary by country.

No reported repair costs yet for this model.

Median months to failure

9.5

Failure reports

2

View →

Median repair cost

—

Still recommend

—

% repaired

—

% mfr warranty

—

% extended warranty

—

% support helpful

—

Use these reports as a risk signal, then check current listings before you buy.

Search this model on Amazon

As an Amazon Associate, After Warranty may earn from qualifying purchases.

What breaks?

What breaks? · reports

Electrical shock / short

Gas Ranges or Ovens (279)

1 months

Government / agencyIndexed Oct 22, 2026Source-linkedVerify source — SaferProducts.gov incident

SaferProducts.gov consumer incident report 20110820-FB8E0-2147476068. Matched catalog product: Amana AGR5844VDW. Incident: I recently bought an Amana gas range, Model AGR5844VDW. I've used it approximately 4 times. The knobs on the front of the range are extremely easy to turn on inadvertently. They protrude rather far from the surface of the stove, they are pointed so they can catch on things, and you only need to push it in very slightly to turn the knob. Out of the 4 times I've used the range, I've unknowingly turned the gas on 3 times while either removing things from the stove or cleaning the stovetop. I didn't realize the gas was turned on until we smelled gas in the house. Once it happened twice in one evening! The last time it happened, we didn't realize it, and we woke up in the morning to our home filled with gas. It had been running all night. We also have a greyhound, who is the height of the stove knobs, so he could easily have bumped it with his nose and turned it on. A small child could very easily reach up and slightly turn the knob to get the gas going. We do not know how it got turned on the last time, but it could easily have blown up the house, it was that bad. We were afraid to turn on any fans because we didn't want to create a spark and cause an explosion. We had to open the doors and windows and evacuate until it cleared up a little. The store we bought the appliance from (Frank's Appliance in Bradley, IL) said they had a similar complaint from another customer. They called Amana and were told they made it that way because they got complaints from people with arthritis tha

UnverifiedEvidence ★★★★☆
View report details

Months until failure

1 months

Repair cost

Not stated

Repaired

Not stated

Manufacturer warranty

Not stated

Extended warranty

Not stated

Support helpful

Not stated

Would recommend

Not stated

AI extraction confidence

92%

Verification status

Unverified

Evidence quality

★★★★☆ (4/5)

Discussion

Fire / ignition

Gas Ranges or Ovens (279)

18 months

Government / agencyIndexed Oct 22, 2026Source-linkedVerify source — SaferProducts.gov incident

SaferProducts.gov consumer incident report 20121119-EBEF8-2147461785. Severity: Incident, No Injury. Product: Amana AGR5844VDW (Amana 5.0 cu. ft. Self-Cleaning Gas Range Model AGR5844VDW). Incident: The Amana 5 cu.ft Self Cleaning Gas Range, model AGR5844VDW2 is unsafe, in that the knobs on the front of the stove do not lock in the off position and easily flip to the gas-on position before finding the "light" position, causing gas to emit into the room without lighting. In other words, this has happened to me twice when just brushing by with a towel or bag of lettuce, without my knowledge until the gas smell filled the house. The first time was when I wiped down the surface of the range. I had a cold and was home alone for several hours before my husband came home and noticed the "funny smell", which due to my cold I could not smell. We evacuated and aired out the house. The second time was when I carried items from the refrigerator and it was probably the bag of lettuce that brushed against the knobs. There is no noise when it happens, as it doesn't turn all the way to the "light" function wherein the clicking sound happens until the unit fires up. Again my husband happened to be in the kitchen, and after the first incident watches the knobs more closely and noticed that it happened again. We caught it before we had to evacuate, or worse before we lit something else in the vicinity. The range was purchased at The Home Depot in The Dalles, Oregon, on May 14, 2011.

UnverifiedEvidence ★★★★☆
View report details

Months until failure

18 months

Repair cost

Not stated

Repaired

Not stated

Manufacturer warranty

Not stated

Extended warranty

Not stated

Support helpful

Not stated

Would recommend

Not stated

AI extraction confidence

84%

Verification status

Unverified

Evidence quality

★★★★☆ (4/5)

Discussion

Compare nearby models

Similar products

Stay ahead of failures

Notify me about this model

Get an email when a new source-linked failure report is published for the Amana AGR5844VDW.

We only email when a new published report is added for Amana AGR5844VDW. No spam, unsubscribe by contacting support.

Contribute signal

Had a failure with this model?

Add your experience and help future shoppers understand what happens after the warranty.

Submit your experience