Nest Learning Thermostat (2nd Gen)

Smart Home Device

Nest Learning Thermostat (2nd Gen)

7 source-linked failure reports. Most reported: Overheating. Typical failure around 2.5 yr.

Reliability signal C · Early signal · data confidence Low

7 confirmed failure reports

Reliability summary

What is likely to go wrong, when it happens, and how expensive it can be — from source-linked failure reports. Counts are reports in our database, not a population failure rate. Methodology →

Reliability signal

C

7 confirmed failure reports · Early signal · Data confidence: Low

Most common issue
Overheating
Typical first failure
2.5 yr
Median of confirmed reports with timing
Median repair cost
—
Reported costs only · market varies
Highest reported repair
—
Not a quote · costs differ by country

What breaks?

Failure types

Click a type in the reports section below to filter.

  • Overheating2 · 28.6%
  • Fire / ignition2 · 28.6%
  • Stopped working / malfunction1 · 14.3%
  • Battery failure1 · 14.3%
  • HVAC control failure stuck heat on; warranty denied as "incompatible"1 · 14.3%

When does it break?

Failure timing

Months after purchase, using reports that included timing.

What does it cost?

Reported repair costs

Distribution of owner-reported repair costs— not a quote or guarantee. Labor and parts prices vary by country.

No reported repair costs yet for this model.

Median months to failure

29.5

Failure reports

7

View →

Median repair cost

—

Still recommend

0%

% repaired

0%

% mfr warranty

0%

% extended warranty

—

% support helpful

0%

Use these reports as a risk signal, then check current listings before you buy.

Search this model on Amazon

As an Amazon Associate, After Warranty may earn from qualifying purchases.

Keep researching

What breaks?

What breaks? · reports

Overheating

Combination Fire/Smoke Alarm and Carbon Monoxide Detector (714)

Government / agencyIndexed Nov 11, 2026Source-linkedVerify source — SaferProducts.gov incident

SaferProducts.gov consumer incident report 20210717-CF2D3-2147362802. Matched catalog product: Nest Learning Thermostat (2nd Gen). Source model text: Nest Protect 2nd Gen. Incident: This morning I woke up to chirping of my 4-5 year old google nest protect carbon monoxide and smoke detector (manufactured June 2016). I then got a notification that the batteries needed to be replaced. The batteries are the original Energizer lithium ion ones that came with the unit.

UnverifiedEvidence ★★★★☆
View report details

Months until failure

Not stated

Repair cost

Not stated

Repaired

Not stated

Manufacturer warranty

Not stated

Extended warranty

Not stated

Support helpful

Not stated

Would recommend

Not stated

AI extraction confidence

86%

Verification status

Unverified

Evidence quality

★★★★☆ (4/5)

Discussion

Overheating

Combination Fire/Smoke Alarm and Carbon Monoxide Detector (714)

Government / agencyIndexed Nov 11, 2026Source-linkedVerify source — SaferProducts.gov incident

SaferProducts.gov consumer incident report 20220715-0FA76-2147354998. Severity: Incident, No Injury. Matched catalog product: Nest Learning Thermostat (2nd Gen). Source model text: Nest protect 2nd generation. Incident: My nest protect began beeping while I was asleep to indicate the battery was low. I opened up the battery cover and one of the batteries was extremely hot. According to the Nest app it had been indicating the low battery status for around 20 minutes before I woke up. It would have been very dangerous if it had been allowed to overheat longer or if I wasn�t home.

UnverifiedEvidence ★★★★☆
View report details

Months until failure

Not stated

Repair cost

Not stated

Repaired

Not stated

Manufacturer warranty

Not stated

Extended warranty

Not stated

Support helpful

Not stated

Would recommend

Not stated

AI extraction confidence

86%

Verification status

Unverified

Evidence quality

★★★★☆ (4/5)

Discussion

Fire / ignition

Combination Fire/Smoke Alarm and Carbon Monoxide Detector (714)

59 months

Government / agencyIndexed Oct 22, 2026Source-linkedVerify source — SaferProducts.gov incident

SaferProducts.gov consumer incident report 20260201-490D7-2147323986. Severity: No Incident, No Injury. Matched catalog product: Nest Learning Thermostat (2nd Gen). Incident: Nest Protect started chirping unexpectedly with no prior low battery warning. When changing the [REDACTED] Lithium batteries one of the batteries was too hot to touch. I believe this to be a fire hazard and a major fault for a fire / carbon monoxide detector.

UnverifiedEvidence ★★★★☆
View report details

Months until failure

59 months

Repair cost

Not stated

Repaired

Not stated

Manufacturer warranty

Not stated

Extended warranty

Not stated

Support helpful

Not stated

Would recommend

Not stated

AI extraction confidence

86%

Verification status

Unverified

Evidence quality

★★★★☆ (4/5)

Discussion

Stopped working / malfunction

Thermostats (For Heating or Cooling Systems) (340)

12 months

Government / agencyIndexed Oct 22, 2026Source-linkedVerify source — SaferProducts.gov incident

SaferProducts.gov consumer incident report 20190720-B453B-2147379786. Matched catalog product: Nest Learning Thermostat (2nd Gen). Source model text: E. Incident: Thermostat stopped working.. It read 82 degrees whnd the house was 71. I realized this temperature was because the thermostat was warm to the touch.

UnverifiedEvidence ★★★★☆
View report details

Months until failure

12 months

Repair cost

Not stated

Repaired

Not stated

Manufacturer warranty

Not stated

Extended warranty

Not stated

Support helpful

Not stated

Would recommend

Not stated

AI extraction confidence

92%

Verification status

Unverified

Evidence quality

★★★★☆ (4/5)

Discussion

Battery failure

Thermostats (For Heating or Cooling Systems) (340)

Government / agencyIndexed Oct 22, 2026Source-linkedVerify source — SaferProducts.gov incident

SaferProducts.gov consumer incident report 20220525-E416C-2147356011. Severity: Incident, No Injury. Matched catalog product: Nest Learning Thermostat (2nd Gen). Source model text: Nest 3rd gen thermostat. Incident: We recently had our heat pump replaced on our house.� We had a 3rd gen Nest installed as well by the installer, and the unit had a c wire included as well.� We received a message saying that the room that this nest was in had reached a dangerous heat level, I went to check the room, and the door handle was hot to the touch and the nest had turned the hearing unit on, on a day where the outside temperature was 87f.� The room temperature had gone up to 115 degrees, and I had to switch off the heat pump at the breaker.� We have 2 other nest units in our house attached to conventional HVAC systems and have never experienced anything like that before.� We called our installer who checked the unit and confirmed that the wiring was correct and the correct voltage was coming through. A week later the unit spiked again, sending a warning that the temp had gone up to 109F.� This time the installer put in a brand new nest.� Its clear this unit had a battery failure and tried to charge itself by turning on the heat (why it would go into heat mode on a hot spring day is beyond me), but its clear the battery process is flawed and a secondary back up system needs to be incorporated into this thermostat.� Nest needs to monitor units for low battery issues and warn homeowners of this possibility.� I will be contacting the consumer product safety board on this issue.

UnverifiedEvidence ★★★★☆
View report details

Months until failure

Not stated

Repair cost

Not stated

Repaired

Not stated

Manufacturer warranty

Not stated

Extended warranty

Not stated

Support helpful

Not stated

Would recommend

Not stated

AI extraction confidence

86%

Verification status

Unverified

Evidence quality

★★★★☆ (4/5)

Discussion

Fire / ignition

Combination Fire/Smoke Alarm and Carbon Monoxide Detector (714)

47 months

Government / agencyIndexed Oct 22, 2026Source-linkedVerify source — SaferProducts.gov incident

SaferProducts.gov consumer incident report 20210928-80850-2147360364. Severity: Incident, No Injury. Matched catalog product: Nest Learning Thermostat (2nd Gen). Source model text: Nest Protect 2nd Generation. Incident: On Sunday, September 26, I was awakened early in the morning by the chirping of my Nest Protect smoke detector. I had not received any warnings in the Nest app that the batteries were low. The batteries are the Energizer lithium that came with the unit. Three of the six batteries were too hot to touch. I removed the batteries from the detector and put them outside, and have stopped using the detector. This Protect is a second-generation unit manufactured on September 14, 2017, and the serial number is 06AA01AC371703AE. I have four other Nest Protects in my home and am concerned about them having the same issue. I bought these devices to protect my home against fire, not start fires.

UnverifiedEvidence ★★★★☆
View report details

Months until failure

47 months

Repair cost

Not stated

Repaired

Not stated

Manufacturer warranty

Not stated

Extended warranty

Not stated

Support helpful

Not stated

Would recommend

Not stated

AI extraction confidence

86%

Verification status

Unverified

Evidence quality

★★★★☆ (4/5)

Discussion

HVAC control failure stuck heat on; warranty denied as "incompatible"

["Thermostat control electronics","Heating relay control"]

1 months

Retailer reviewIndexed Aug 20, 2026Source-linkedVerify source — Amazon review

Amazon.com 1-star review by Kiscica (title: "Stay away - stay far, far away!"; Verified Purchase). About three weeks after install the Nest failed so heating stayed stuck on while cooling also ran (apartment climbed to ~89°F). Nest support said voltage spikes make the system "incompatible" and declined to treat it as a warranty hardware defect, directing the buyer to return via Amazon instead.

UnverifiedEvidence ★★★☆☆Not under mfr warranty
View report details

Months until failure

1 months

Repair cost

Not stated

Repaired

No

Manufacturer warranty

No

Extended warranty

Not stated

Support helpful

No

Would recommend

No

AI extraction confidence

92%

Verification status

Unverified

Evidence quality

★★★☆☆ (3/5)

Discussion

Compare nearby models

Similar products

Stay ahead of failures

Notify me about this model

Get an email when a new source-linked failure report is published for the Nest Learning Thermostat (2nd Gen).

We only email when a new published report is added for Nest Learning Thermostat (2nd Gen). No spam, unsubscribe by contacting support.

Contribute signal

Had a failure with this model?

Add your experience and help future shoppers understand what happens after the warranty.

Submit your experience