Side-by-side reliability

Tesla Model Y 2020 vs Volkswagen ID.4 2025

Compare reliability signal, data confidence, common failures, typical age, and reported repair cost. Warranty window reference: 36–36 months depending on category.

Counts are reported failures in our database, not a population failure rate. How we measure →

Compare up to four products →

Model A

Tesla Model Y 2020

Reliability signal B · Early signal · data confidence Low

12 failure reports · Early signal · Low confidence
Most common failure
Electrical system failure
Typical failure age
3.1 yr
Median repair cost
—
Highest reported repair
—

Median months

37.5

% mfr warranty

—

After warranty reports

6

Avg repair cost

—

Top failure categories

  • Electrical system failure5
  • Other4
  • Steering failure1
  • Airbag / restraint failure1
Open full product page

Model B

Volkswagen ID.4 2025

Reliability signal — · Early signal · data confidence Low

12 failure reports · Early signal · Low confidence
Most common failure
Electrical system failure
Typical failure age
7 mo
Median repair cost
—
Highest reported repair
—

Median months

7

% mfr warranty

—

After warranty reports

0

Avg repair cost

—

Top failure categories

  • Electrical system failure7
  • Other2
  • Structure / body failure1
  • Airbag / restraint failure1
Open full product page

Decision notes

How to read this comparison

  • Sample size: Tesla Model Y 2020 has 12 failure reports; Volkswagen ID.4 2025 has 12. Similar report density. Thin samples are weak evidence.
  • Timing: typical first failure 3.1 yr vs 7 mo. Earlier median in our timed sample: Volkswagen ID.4 2025.
  • After typical warranty: 6 vs 0 timed reports past the category warranty window.
  • Overlapping failure themes: Electrical system failure; Other; Airbag / restraint failure; Structure / body failure.

Counts are reported failures in our database, not a population failure rate. How we measure →

More comparisons