Structural / mechanical failure
Bicycles and Accessories, (Excl.mountain or All-terrain) (5040)
SaferProducts.gov consumer incident report 20230408-7DB2C-2147348214. Severity: Incident, No Injury. Product: Cannondale System Six (road bicycle, 58cm, System Six, R154505 (2007 model)). Incident: I have an older Cannondale bicycle bought used in in 2013 with 2400 miles on it. I stored the bike until 2019 and then began riding it. In 2022 the arm on the carbon crankset broke at the pedal attachment and nearly caused a crash. I replaced the carbon arm with a metal arm and continued using the bike until the other carbon arm on the right hand side broke at the same place. While searching for a replacement part I discovered a safety recall #07-206 for Cannondale "bicycles with carbon cranksets." I took the broken parts and bicycle to Orange Cycle, the local Cannondale dealer for evaluation. I was told that the Cannondale recall was for a heat treat issue on the aluminum tube in the crank arm assembly and not the integrity of the carbon arms. My concern is that the recall hazard: "The bicycle's crankset could break, posing a fall hazard to the user." actually did happen two times and Cannondale is okay with it. The recall requires me to "stop using the recalled product immediately" which I did because it is broken and unusable, but even if I replace the broken parts with exact replacement parts I am afraid of an accident. Have there been other accidents related to this recall? Is the recall only intended to address the heat treated tube or is the more important carbon arm breakage also included? I am concerned about the real probability of riders falling when fatigue causes the pedal to break from the carbon arm after many repetitive cycles.
UnverifiedEvidence ★★★★☆View report detailsHide report details
Structural / mechanical failure
Bicycles and Accessories, (Excl.mountain or All-terrain) (5040)
Months until failure
Not stated
Repair cost
Not stated
Repaired
Not stated
Manufacturer warranty
Not stated
Extended warranty
Not stated
Support helpful
Not stated
Would recommend
Not stated
AI extraction confidence
84%
Verification status
Unverified
Evidence quality
★★★★☆ (4/5)