Product image pending

We track images separately from defect reports.

Lawn Equipment

Carrier 58MTA

1 source-linked failure report. Most reported: Battery failure. Typical failure around 17.8 yr.

Reliability signal — · Insufficient data · data confidence Very Low

1 confirmed failure reports

Reliability summary

What is likely to go wrong, when it happens, and how expensive it can be — from source-linked failure reports. Counts are reports in our database, not a population failure rate. Methodology →

Reliability signal

—

1 confirmed failure report · Insufficient data · Data confidence: Very Low

Need at least 5 confirmed failure-signal reports before showing an A–F grade.

Most common issue
Battery failure
Typical first failure
17.8 yr
Median of confirmed reports with timing
Median repair cost
—
Reported costs only · market varies
Highest reported repair
—
Not a quote · costs differ by country

What breaks?

Failure types

Click a type in the reports section below to filter.

  • Battery failure1 · 100%

When does it break?

Failure timing

Months after purchase, using reports that included timing.

What does it cost?

Reported repair costs

Distribution of owner-reported repair costs— not a quote or guarantee. Labor and parts prices vary by country.

No reported repair costs yet for this model.

Median months to failure

213

Failure reports

1

View →

Median repair cost

—

Still recommend

—

% repaired

—

% mfr warranty

—

% extended warranty

—

% support helpful

—

Use these reports as a risk signal, then check current listings before you buy.

Search this model on Amazon

As an Amazon Associate, After Warranty may earn from qualifying purchases.

Keep researching

What breaks?

What breaks? · reports

Battery failure

Gas Furnaces (310)

213 months

Government / agencyIndexed Nov 11, 2026Source-linkedVerify source — SaferProducts.gov incident

SaferProducts.gov consumer incident report 20200515-8795F-1980106. Severity: Injury, No First Aid or Medical Attention Received. Product: Carrier 58MTA (gas furnace). Incident: Between March and April, the consumer noticed that his wife was coughing. The consumer was also having issues with his feet. They were feeling weird and swelling. Around the first of April the consumer noticed a rubber or burning smell in the home. On May 9, the consumer was outside of the home and there was a smell of gas. The consumer called the gas company who came out immediately. The problem was with the heat exchange in the furnace. The consumer contacted the furnace company, who also came out on May 11 and condemned the furnace. The consumer checked on line and saw that there was a class action suit in 2007 in reference to the secondary heat exchange but he was never notified. The consumer check online and found out that the issues that he and his wife were having were symptoms of being exposed to polycarbonates in the furnace. No medical attention was required.

UnverifiedEvidence ★★★★☆
View report details

Months until failure

213 months

Repair cost

Not stated

Repaired

Not stated

Manufacturer warranty

Not stated

Extended warranty

Not stated

Support helpful

Not stated

Would recommend

Not stated

AI extraction confidence

84%

Verification status

Unverified

Evidence quality

★★★★☆ (4/5)

Discussion

Compare nearby models

Similar products

Stay ahead of failures

Notify me about this model

Get an email when a new source-linked failure report is published for the Carrier 58MTA.

We only email when a new published report is added for Carrier 58MTA. No spam, unsubscribe by contacting support.

Contribute signal

Had a failure with this model?

Add your experience and help future shoppers understand what happens after the warranty.

Submit your experience